• Español
  • English
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • rss
  • Español
  • English
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • rss
TNI D&D
  • Home
  • About us
    • About us
    • People
    • Partners
    • Researchers
    • Contact us
    • In the media
    • Newsletter
  • Newsroom
    • Press contacts
    • Press releases
    • Resources
    • Drugs in the news
  • Issues
    • Drug policy debate in the Americas
    • Decriminalization
    • Proportionality of sentences
    • Harm reduction
    • Reclassification of substances
    • Safer crack use
    • Human rights
    • Regulation
    • Unscheduling the coca leaf
    • Ending the war on drugs
    • Alternative development
    • Cannabis
    • Producers of Crops
    • Law enforcement
    • ATS, Mild stimulants & NPS
    • European Drug Policy
    • Money Laundering
  • UN Drug
    Control
    • Conventions
    • UNODC
    • CND
    • INCB
    • UNGASS
  • Country
    information
    • Drug Law Reform on the Map
    • Central America
      • El Salvador
      • Guatemala
      • Honduras
      • Costa Rica
    • Latin America
      • Argentina
      • Bolivia
      • Paraguay
      • Brazil
      • Chile
      • Colombia
      • Ecuador
      • Peru
      • Uruguay
      • Venezuela
    • Mexico
    • Caribbean
      • Jamaica
      • Belize
    • Afghanistan
  • Events
    • Expert Seminars
    • Informal Policy Dialogues
    • Public Events
    • Judges for Law Reform
  • Publications
    • Drug Policy Briefings
    • Drug Law Reform
    • Legislative Reform Series
    • The Human Face
    • Drugs & conflict
    • Drugs and the Law (CEDD)
      • Systems overload
    • Drug Markets and Violence
  • Weblog

 

Statement of Evo Morales

Evo Morales, photo by  Alain BachellierExecutive Secretary of the Five Federations of Lowland Peasants in Bolivia and President of the Andean Confederation of Coca Leaf Producers.
Meant to be presented to the United Nations General Assembly Special Session on Drugs (UNGASS) New York, June 8-10, 1998

 

Mr. President of this Extraordinary United Nations Assembly, Delegates.

I think this will not be the last international conference concerning drugs. As is often the case, the conclusions and recommendations are already prepared, and I know that you have invested a great deal of time in their elaboration. I understand that for this reason you wilt try to ensure they are not changed. None the less, I want to express my thanks for the opportunity to address you, humbly and sincerely, but also firmly and clearly, as one more peasant among many who cultivate the coca leaf in Bolivia, Peru and Colombia.

The Coca Leaf

Cultivation of the coca leaf was never a crime. Rather, in the Andean world it was a privilege. The climate makes cultivation hard, but rewarding as well, given that coca has many advantages agriculturally and positive uses for consumers. As you know, coca is a perennial shrub that can flourish in even the poorest soils, has less of an environmental impact than other plants; is resistant to pests and plagues; and the leaf is easier to store and transport than other agricultural products. And you should know as well that traditional medicine in the Andes has used coca for centuries to alleviate stomach problems, stop haemorrhaging, close wounds, and alleviate pain. With coca, laborers, maximize use of their energies and travellers counteract the problems associated with high attitude. Andean families express an affection for and solidarity with coca. How could producing such a beneficial plant not be a dignified activity?

But cultural prejudice has always gotten in the way of understanding this. From the beginnings of our colonial history, those who condemned the Indians as savage and ignorant also condemned coca along with a culture different from their own. Our music was not music, it was folklore, our language only a dialect, our religion, idolatry, our coca a vice. And they tried to impose their music, their language, their religion and their vices.

With the passing of time the prejudices took the form of "studies" that were the basis for the unjust Convention of 1961, which proposed to eradicate cultivation and eliminate consumption of coca. This condemnation of coca, based on false "proofs", has never been rectified, though much has been learned about coca in the past 37 years. And now the abusive use of coca has attached a new blame to the leaf: that of being the raw material for an illegalized stimulant.

When a person trips over a stone and then blames the stone, we call that person immature, one who avoids responsibility. What can we say, then, of the states and societies which blame drugs for social problems?

And just as the person who blames stones for tripping, will never walk peacefully, always considering stones to be a threat, neither will we be able to resolve our social problems if we blame them on drugs.

The War on Drugs

International conferences on drugs have not resolved the problem of drug production and consumption. Moreover, it might be said they have been an aggravation, by adding new dimensions to the problem. Today more resources, more police, more judges, prosecutors, and prisons are dedicated to the problem than at any time in human history. Today more people than ever are in jail accused of producing, trafficking or selling drugs. Thus, more families than ever suffer the abandonment and difficulties of a judicial and law enforcement system that grows and grows, but does not solve problems. Today the production, use and consumption of more and more substances is prohibited or regulated. Nonetheless, in the world today there are more and more producers and consumers of drugs than at any previous time in history.

Let us recognize that this war is a failure. Today we are farther than ever from reaching this goal, so ambitious and unrealistic, of a "world free of drugs".

I am not content. The peasants are not content. No one should be happy when humanity's resources are wasted in this way.

This discontent makes suspicious. When failure is so complete and so often repeated it suggests only one thing: it is deliberate. It suggests that no one is interested in solving the real underlying problems, that this is a hypocritical war, which deliberately diverts and distracts peoples' attention.

In the "war on drugs" something very strange happens. Whether the battles in this war are won or lost, the bureaucracies always find arguments to secure support for their work. When battles are won, they receive support because they have proven they are on the right path, thus justifying more. When they lose, they receive support because they haven't done enough and therefore need more. In this war failure has become a huge business. a business that nurtures bureaucracies, and nurtures them well. They always need more, to keep on failing.

We have to ask ourselves: Are we willing to persist in this failure?

Correct Answers to the Wrong Questions

How to address the drug problem has been and will be discussed here. Many of the answers will undoubtedly be good, sincere ones. But the policies will continue to be bad if we keep providing answers to the wrong questions.

The drug war has been guided by the wrong preoccupations, such as: Which is the most heavily consumed drug? How much of that drug is consumed? How and where is it trafficked? These questions have brought us failure because they have impeded us from asking more important questions, the questions that would take us to the bottom of things because they obligate us to look at ourselves. No drug policy will be adequate as long as these questions remain unanswered: Why are drums being consumed? Why do people consume some drugs, and not others? And most importantly, why are there people who need drugs?

It will not be easy to provide answers. The Americans will have te explain the hopelessness in the African-American and Hispanic neighbourhoods, the voids in the lives of elites, the cult of chemicals among the middle classes. And we, the Bolivians, Peruvians and Colombians will have to explain the poverty of our majorities, the lack of opportunities for those of us who want to live better, the ambitions of these who imitate the rich and famous. It will be difficult to answer these questions, but when we do, we will be able te confront these problems. And it doesn't matter if coca is cocaine or not, if cocaine is better or worse than amphetamine, if tobacco and alcohol should be legal or not. The war on drugs will have been transformed in what it should be: a struggle to humanize life itself.

We aren't the Problem, We don't want to be the Victims

Drug policies, though they may be incapable of resolving underlying problems, affect fundamental aspects of out lives. All of us are hurt when resources are diverted or laws are modified to limit our rights. But the Indians and peasants of Latin America suffer more. Our coca plants are declared illegal, we are characterized and treated as delinquents, we are harassed and abused constantly. They say they use the carrot and the stick on us. rewards and punishment. And they call it the "Plan for Dignity".

They say the carrot, the reward, is alternative development and the war on poverty. They make promises to invest even that which they don't have. But their development model is based on the reduction of coca prices. That is, it is based on the impoverishment of the peasants. And then they expect the impoverished peasant to risk cultivation of new products that have not been adapted to the context and don't have markets.

The governments are using poverty as a weapon in the war on drugs. Is this just? Is this morally correct? The reduction of coca prices, moreover, not only hurts the peasant but helps the buyer, both legal and illegal. These are the ones who take advantage of the carrot.

What to say about the use of the stick? This year alone in Bolivia government forces have provoked the death of 12 people in the their attempts to impose the forced eradication of coca crops. This rnortality rate is many times greater than the mortality rate caused by cocaine abuse in the United States. Studies show that of every 100,000 cocaine consumers, 4 die from abuse or intoxication. Based on what we have lived this year alone, the war on drugs is producing the death of 12 of every 15,000 peasants (or 80 of every 100,000), The remedy is worse than the disease. Governments feel obligated and are pressured remember the certification process- to increase the dosage. And they have ever lesser capacity to dialogue and seek alternative solutions.

We, the peasants, have mobilized to defend our livelihoods, and we have sought agreement on policies, putting forward formulas for mediation and negotiation. We asked help to industrialize coca to avoid its illegal use. We requested markets for our other crops. We want development in our farms, not in governmental offices. The government rejects us with the argument that its policies must meet international commitments. This means that Assemblies such as this one, which formulate and approve conventions and international treaties, are complicit in and co-responsible for the repression. Who here is ready to answer for the deaths of my brothers and sisters, for the painful failures of this hypocritical war, and for the enormous profits that from it accrue to a minority?

I am a peasant, a South American Indian, from the Aymara group, inheritor of the culture of millennia, and also the oppression of centuries. I am a citizen of a small, poor country, and I am part of a global world. That is why I feel I have the right to ask you to be honest in your refections, and cautious in your decisions. Don't blame your stumble on the stones, and seek ways to reserve people's problems, the problems of marginality that lead some to abuse drugs, and others to survive cultivating the raw materials to produce them.

We are not the problem; we want to be part of the solution. For this reason I ask you: don't continue to push us, cease to pressure us, don't convert us into illegals just because you don't want to or can't admit to the true dimension of your problems. We hope for, we ask, we demand that you respect us as human beings, that vou give us opportunities as peasants, that you listen to us as citizens. We are not the problem. Help us be part of the solution.

 
  • Labels
    traditional growers | coca

Drugs in the News

  • Cannabis cafés and self-growing: Czechia presents draft of new marijuana law
    11.01.2024
  • Minister signs bill banning recreational use of weed
    08.01.2024
  • As the mayor of Amsterdam, I can see the Netherlands risks becoming a narco-state
    05.01.2024
  • Barcelona city council threatens to shut down cannabis social clubs
    04.01.2024
  • Swiss capital Bern considers legal cocaine project
    20.12.2023
  • High time: after five years, Dutch start legal cannabis trial
    15.12.2023
More news

Weblog

    Willful blindness: INCB can find nothing good to say on cannabis legalisation
    14.03.2023
More weblog

Hilites

Balancing Treaty Stability and Change

balancing hilite

Inter se modification of the UN drug control conventions to facilitate cannabis regulation


Connecting the dots...

connecting dots hilite

Human rights, illicit cultivation and alternative development


Morocco and Cannabis

morocco cannabis hilite

Reduction, containment or acceptance


The Rise and Decline of Cannabis Prohibition

rise decline hilite

The History of Cannabis in the UN Drug Control System and Options For Reform


Tags

10-year Review  20 1998 UNGASS  26 2005 CND debate  8 2016 UNGASS  126 2019 HLM  5 activism  38 afghanistan  25 show all

Tags

10-year Review  20 1998 UNGASS  26 2005 CND debate  8 2016 UNGASS  126 2019 HLM  5 activism  38 afghanistan  25 hide
africa  14 albania  14 alternative development  120 alternatives to policing  2 amnesty  89 amphetamine  1 amsterdam  30 appellation of origin  3 argentina  32 asean  9 ATS  15 australia  109 austria  5 ayahuasca  6 bahamas  4 ballot 2012  155 banking  52 barbados  11 belgium  46 belize  10 bermuda  15 bhang  15 bolivia  118 brazil  95 brownfield doctrine  24 burma  45 california  216 cambodia  12 canada  543 cannabinoids  107 cannabis  3255 cannabis clubs  230 cannabis industry  417 caribbean  148 caricom  33 cbd oil  1 central america  5 chile  21 china  46 civil society  37 CND  131 coca  220 cocaine  95 coffee shop  230 cognitive decline  30 colombia  160 colorado  163 compulsary detention  19 conflict  4 conventions  277 corporate capture  59 corruption  5 costa rica  10 crack  55 craft cannabis  31 crime  92 czech republic  54 dark net  4 death penalty  3 decertification  1 decriminalization  935 deforestation  11 denmark  132 drug checking  41 drug consumption rooms  193 drug courts  22 drug markets  147 drug policy index  2 drug testing  7 drug trade  60 e-cigarettes  1 e-joint  2 ecstasy  70 ecuador  22 egypt  16 el salvador  2 environment  38 eradication  129 essential medicines  25 estonia  2 eswatini  7 ethiopia  3 european drug policy  119 expert advisory group  9 extrajudicial killings  95 fair trade  16 fentanyl  84 france  119 fumigation  27 gateway theory  29 georgia  3 germany  217 ghana  18 global commission  46 greece  19 guatemala  32 guatemala initiative  47 harm reduction  348 hemp  44 heroin  139 heroin assisted treatment  80 HIV/AIDS  61 home cultivation  124 honduras  4 human rights  259 ICC  1 illinois  10 incarceration  53 INCB  143 india  102 indigenous rights  1 indonesia  35 informal drug policy dialogues  22 inter se modification  17 iran  14 ireland  16 israel  63 italy  42 jamaica  176 japan  3 kava  4 kazakhstan  5 kenya  11 ketamine  27 khat  37 kratom  33 kyrgyzstan  1 laos  2 latin american debate  115 law enforcement  432 lebanon  43 legal highs  64 legalization  1709 lesotho  10 local customization  11 luxembourg  60 malawi  4 malaysia  7 malta  58 medical cannabis  665 mental health  45 methamphetamine  49 mexico  211 Mid-Term Review  1 mild stimulants  46 money laundering  55 morocco  128 naloxone  16 nepal  7 netherlands  341 new york  34 new zealand  67 NIDA  5 nigeria  1 nitrous oxide  9 norway  18 NPS  10 opinion polls  132 opioids  153 opium  94 oregon  29 overdose kits  4 pakistan  9 panama  5 paraguay  4 pardon  2 patents  18 peace  24 peru  45 peyote  3 philippines  89 pilot project  137 pleasure  5 poland  2 police pacification  18 portugal  68 potency  2 precursors  7 prevention  3 prison situation  101 prohibition  158 proportionality  110 psychedelics  13 psychosis  57 puerto rico  3 racism  29 reclassification  119 recriminalisation  42 regulation  1454 russia  36 sacramental use  11 safe supply  36 safer crack  29 scheduling  29 scientific research  145 sdg  2 security  14 senegal  1 sentencing  67 singapore  7 social justice  83 somalia  7 south africa  83 spain  81 st lucia  9 st vincent and grenadines  31 substance-use disorder  20 substitution treatment  31 sweden  31 switzerland  162 synthetic cannabinoids  31 taxation  58 teen use  43 thailand  78 thresholds  64 tobacco industry  17 traditional growers  162 tramadol  17 treatment  29 trinidad & tobago  15 tunisia  14 UK  282 UN Common Position  1 UN drug control  444 UNGASS  58 UNODC  111 uruguay  146 US drug policy  1192 vaping  2 venezuela  5 vietnam  5 violence  134 WHO  66 world drug report  11 yemen  6

This website

UN Drug Control

In 2011 the 1961 UN Single Convention on drugs will be in place for 50 years. In 2012 the international drug control system will exist 100 years since the International Opium Convention was signed in 1912 in The Hague. Does it still serve its purpose or is a reform of the UN Drug Conventions needed? This site provides critical background.

Drug Law Reform on the map

dlronthemap_und

Copyright © 2024 Drug Law Reform in Latin America

Website by WebWolf